IoMP 143: Evanescence (Early) - Are They Rock or Metal?
Let’s be honest: the early 2000s were chaos.
If a band had distortion, angst, and someone looking mildly haunted in a music video, they were getting slapped with the “metal” label whether they deserved it or not. And right in the middle of that beautiful mess? Evanescence.
In this episode of Influencers of Metal Podcast, Collin and Tom put Evanescence on trial—focusing strictly on Fallen and The Open Door—to answer one deceptively simple question:
Are they rock… or metal?
What starts as a casual discussion quickly spirals (as it always does) into a full-blown genre autopsy. From the undeniable impact of “Bring Me to Life” to deeper cuts like “Haunted” and “Cloud Nine,” the guys dissect the band’s balance of crushing riffs, orchestral drama, and Amy Lee’s haunting vocal dominance.
They also dig into why Evanescence got lumped in with nu metal (even when it barely makes sense), how bands like Breaking Benjamin and Korn shaped the conversation, and whether one killer riff is enough to tip the scales into metal territory.
👉 Listen now and decide for yourself: is Evanescence metal enough for your playlist, or are they the ultimate gateway drug to heavier music?
DISCLAIMER: Copyright Exceptions under the Copyright Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-42), allowance is made for "fair dealing" for the purposes of criticism or review.
Check out more from the Influencers of Metal Podcast!
Van Halen helped revolutionize guitar playing, inspired generations of metal musicians and laid some of the groundwork for the hair metal explosion — but does that make Van Halen a metal band?
It’s Van Halen Week on the Influencers of Metal Podcast! Collin and Tom continue their quest to find the most metal Guitar Hero game by diving into Guitar Hero: Van Halen.
Hear which records from Galneryus, Haserot, Protest the Hero, Left to Die, Motionless In White, and more survived the chaos on this month’s edition of “What Have You Been Listening To?”
Few bands have disrupted heavy music quite like The Hu. But does that make them rock... or metal?
Festival season has arrived, and so it’s time for us to explore some of the biggest festivals in the world.
Is Sleep Token one of modern metal's greatest success stories—or one of its most overhyped bands?
Collin, Tom and the Pumpkin Queen break down their June listens, listener recommendations, and the albums dominating their playlists — featuring everything from doom metal and hardcore to metalcore madness
Heavy metal didn’t appear overnight. It crawled out of the blues, turned up the distortion, and terrified everyone’s grandparents.
Collin and Tom are travelling to Uzbekistan to uncover one of the world’s lesser-known metal scenes.
Collin and Tom launch their new series “Is It Really a Subgenre?” by diving headfirst into the legendary meme known as Crabcore.
Guitar Hero 5 has Iron Maiden, Rammstein, Dethklok and Children of Bodom… but somehow still only clocks in at around 10% metal. So where does it rank in the “Most Metal Guitar Hero Game” tournament?
Collin and Tom dive into the weirdest, funniest, and most confusing metal covers ever recorded.
This time, metal’s most iconic duo talk about the metal bands they wish were still around.
We're halfway through 2026, so our duo are joined by Chris Thrash to rank their Top 5 albums of the year so far!